Effingham County Refusing to Comply with Open Records Law on Report Related to Commission Candidate

Two days after the election results came in, a man who campaigned as a write-in candidate for county commission in Effingham County received a visit from code enforcement at both his home and his place of business.

Now, the county is refusing to provide specific details and public records regarding the complaint.

Campaign

District 5 incumbent Phil Keifer qualified for the Republican primary without opposition and no Democrat qualified to face him in the November general election. But following the train wreck rollout of Project Camellia, James Daniels announced his write-in candidacy for Effingham County Commission in District 5.

Daniels campaigned as a small business owner and a voice “for the people” during the contentious election cycle, but came up short on November 3. Keifer prevailed 3,182 over Daniels’ 977 write-in votes.

The day after the election, Daniels congratulated the winners on social media and noted that he would be back in the next election cycle.

The same day, November 4, an unknown person submitted a complaint at 3:17 p.m. The complainant stated that Daniels was operating an unlicensed business, had trucks present “mostly in the evenings and on weekends,” and was “possibly” contaminating nearby ponds.

At 10:00 a.m on Thursday, November 5, Daniels received a visit from one of Effingham County’s Code Enforcement officers. The issue: Daniels had commercial trucking vehicles for his business – Trademark Truck Lines Inc – parked on AR-1 property. His business, which is located at 3070 Highway 80 in Bloomingdale, is zoned Agriculture Residential. His property butts up to a gas station on one side and a residential home on the other side. Across the street is an outdoor shed and metal building dealer and a church.

While the vehicles had been parked at his business location for the better part of six years, the county has never enforced the zoning ordinance there.

Employee notes on the incident indicate the complainant submitted the complaint at 3:17 pm and it was immediately assigned to an employee. The complainant then followed-up on the complaint form 40 minutes later to state that it was Trademark Trucks and it was, in fact, a licensed business, not an unlicensed business as previously submitted.

According to documents obtained by TheGeorgiaVirtue, the officer “spoke with Mr. Daniels, the property and business owner. He stated he would take the necessary steps to address the issue.” The county employee gave Daniels 30 days to resolve the issue. Employee notes also indicated that there was no evidence of any type of contamination.

Daniels complied with the directive of Code Enforcement within a week and contacted the county to report that he relocated the trucks.

Before the code enforcement officer could return to the property or update the incident notes, the complainant replied to the updated notes and stated “All fixed ready for that open records request now.”

Three hours later, on November 12, Code Enforcement returned to Daniels’ property for a site visit and noted on the incident report that he “confirmed that all commercial vehicles had been removed from the residential property.” The code enforcement officer subsequently closed the case.

County Refusal to Provide Records Subject to Disclosure

After Daniels’ was deemed “in compliance,” he filed an open records request for the Incident Report and other documentation related to the complaint to inquire when and by whom the issue originated. The county provided the documents, but redacted the complainant name – a clear violation of the Georgia Open Records Act.

There is no provision in Georgia law which permits the county to withhold the complainant name.

Additionally, if a government entity is going to redact any information contained within public records, it must cite the specific code section that authorized the entity to redact that information. Despite repeated requests, the county has refused to provide the unredacted paperwork or a legal provision that permits the county to withhold the information.

Previous Commissioner Commentary on Daniels’ Business

Daniels was the target of District 2 Commissioner Roger Burdette’s ire during the campaign season. On social media, Burdette argued with Daniels on a post about Burdette’s role in getting law enforcement involved in the chalk incident at the county annex. In it, Burdette chastised Daniels about Daniels’ wife wearing “the pants” in their relationship and mentioned that Daniels owned trucks.

“Where else do you want to put your trucks? How about coming off some of that bankroll and do it like the rest of us. Trucks belong in industrial areas, not commercial.”

Pattern of Noncompliance by Effingham County

This is not the first time the Board of Commissioners has violated the Georgia Open Records Act.

The Georgia Virtue previously reported on the county’s noncompliance.

In April 2022, TheGeorgiaVirtue filed a complaint with the Georgia Attorney General’s office over Effingham County’s noncompliance – specifically inadequate records, missed deadlines, an inaccurate statement by employees about whether or not records existed, and an outright refusal to identify documents the county did supply. At the time of the complaint, 43 days had passed since the request was filed with the county. The AG’s office subsequently opened a mediation with the county to facilitate the delivery of the records and the county attorney Lee Newberry chalked the violations up to “a miscommunication.”

Further, for the better part of three years, the Effingham County Transparency Portal where citizens file open records requests, included provisions for ORRs that were in direct conflict with state law. Repeated attempts to bring this to the attention of county officials and the county attorney were ignored.


Note: On the social media post where Burdette made comments directly to Daniels, Burdette stated directly to TheGeorgiaVirtue that he was always open to interviews and welcomed the opportunity to talk. Burdette, however, blocked TheGeorgiaVirtue and all of the participants of the conservation shortly after the dialogue.

Jessica Szilagyi

Jessica Szilagyi is Publisher of TGV News. She focuses primarily on state and local politics as well as issues in law enforcement and corrections. She has a background in Political Science with a focus in local government and has a Master of Public Administration from the University of Georgia.

Jessica is a "Like It Or Not" contributor for Fox5 in Atlanta and co-creator of the Peabody Award-nominated podcast 'Prison Town.'

Sign up for her weekly newsletter: http://eepurl.com/gzYAZT

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Previous Story

Bulloch County Jail Booking & Incident Report – November 18, 2026